Skip to content
Mia Automation
NLEN Sign in Put Mia to workGet started

Agentic AI vs. Generative AI: We Ran the Same Tasks Both Ways

Generative AI produces content when you ask: text, images, code. Agentic AI is given a goal and takes the actions itself, using tools and checking results along the way. Pick generative AI when the output is the deliverable and a person handles the rest; pick an agentic setup when the work involves several actions, live data or files. In our tests the answers were often equally good. What changed was who did the clicking, and whether the task could be done at all.

AI agents and agentic workUpdated 6 min read

Tested by us on 11 November 2026.

The verdict, by situation

  • Use generative AI when the text, image or code itself is what you need, such as a draft email, a summary or a product description, and you're happy to paste it where it goes.
  • Use agentic AI when the job involves acting: reading files, checking live systems, writing results somewhere, or repeating a sequence of steps.
  • Use neither alone for anything that sends, pays or deletes. Let an agent prepare it and keep a person, or a hard rule in code, on the final step.
Animated comparison of the invoice task. As a chat, a person performs seven steps from opening the invoice file to saving the second reminder. As an agent, one instruction is given and the agent reads, matches, gets one shell command refused, writes two files and reports.
Our invoice test, both ways. The answer was the same; the hands-on work moved from the person to the agent.

Today's chat assistants blur the line because they can switch tools on. The model underneath is the same kind of model. "Agentic" describes how it's being run: in a loop, with tools and permission to act.

How we tested

We picked two small tasks from ordinary office work and ran each one twice with the same model on November 11, 2026, on Ubuntu 24.04. The generative run used Claude Code in non-interactive mode with every tool switched off, which makes it behave like a plain chat. The agentic run used the same program with a short list of allowed tools. One run per task and mode, so read the timings as an example, not a benchmark.

  1. Invoices: compare six invoices with a bank export, find what's unpaid or partly paid, and draft reminders for anything overdue. Two traps: one customer paid half, another wrote the invoice number without its dash.
  2. Links: check which of six links in a document still work. Two of them return a 404.

Results side by side

One run per cell. Timings are from the tool's own report.
Task and modeResultTimeTurnsLeft for a person
Invoices, generativeCorrect: €605 and €2,420 overdue, both traps caught11 s17 steps: open and copy two files, paste, save two reminders
Invoices, agenticCorrect, plus a warning that the bank export stopped on Nov 524 s6Review two drafts before sending
Links, generativeDeclined: no way to check, offered a script instead6 s1Run the script, read the output, fix the links
Links, agentic4 working, 2 broken (404), one redirect noted18 s6Fix the two links
Bar chart of manual steps left for a person: invoices as chat 7, invoices as agent 1, links as chat 3, links as agent 1.
Work a person still had to do after each run.

The invoice task shows the usual pattern. Both versions did the reasoning correctly. The chat version stopped where the hands-on work began. The link task shows the harder limit: without tools, a model can't know whether a URL is alive today. The chat version said so and guessed which two looked broken from their paths. It guessed right, but a guess is not a check.

The agent runs also show what supervision looks like. In both tasks it tried a command we hadn't allowed, received a refusal and switched to a permitted route without being told. In the invoice run it wrote the files with the file tool after its shell command was blocked. That is the behavior you want, and it only happens when the limits are set outside the model.

How they compare on what matters

Generative AIAgentic AI
OutputContent: text, images, codeCompleted work: files written, records updated, checks run
Who takes the stepsYouThe system, within limits you set
Speed per answerFaster: one turnSlower: several turns, but no manual steps
CostOne model callMany calls per job; each step costs tokens
Main riskA wrong or made-up answerA wrong action, like an email that can't be unsent
Where your data goesOnly what you paste inWhatever its tools can read, so scope them tightly
Ease for non-programmersVery easyEasy to start, harder to set limits well

Quality. Same model, same reasoning. The agent's edge came from access, not intelligence: it could read the real files and hit the real URLs.

Speed and cost. The chat answered in roughly half the time per task, but a person then had to finish the job. Agent jobs grow with every step. Across 1,221 longer agent jobs we finished since October 4, 2026, the median used $13.44 worth of model time at list API prices, against a few cents for a single chat answer.

Risk and privacy. A chat only sees what you paste. An agent sees what its tools can reach, so give it the narrowest access that works: one folder, read-only where possible, and no sending without a check.

Is ChatGPT generative AI or an agent?

Both, depending on what's switched on. A plain conversation with ChatGPT or Claude is generative AI. Once it browses, runs code or edits files toward a goal you set, it's working agentically. Coding agents such as Codex and Claude Code are agentic by default.

What we use ourselves

We use plain generative output for first drafts and quick answers, and agents for anything with more than one action: research with sources, building and testing code, preparing customer messages. Our agents never get the last word on sending or paying; a rule in code decides that. What annoys us about agents is the cost of long runs and the time it takes to set good limits. We have no paid relationship with any of the vendors mentioned and use no affiliate links.

Questions

What is the difference between agentic AI and generative AI?

Generative AI produces content and stops. Agentic AI pursues a goal by taking actions with tools and checking the results. In our invoice test both gave the same correct answer, but the chat left a person seven manual steps and the agent left a review.

Is agentic AI better than generative AI?

Not by default. It's better when the work involves actions or live data, as in our link check, which the chat couldn't do at all. For a draft or a summary, generative AI is faster and cheaper.

Can generative AI become agentic?

Yes. The same model becomes agentic when it runs in a loop with tools and permission to act. Our tests used one program for both modes and only changed which tools were allowed.

What are examples of agentic AI vs generative AI?

Generative: write a payment reminder. Agentic: find which invoices are overdue by checking the bank export, then draft a reminder for each one and save it. Generative: suggest which links might be outdated. Agentic: request each link and report its status.

What are the risks of AI that acts on its own?

Wrong actions, rising costs and access to more data than needed. Keep permissions narrow, put limits in code rather than the prompt, and keep sending, paying and deleting behind a check.

Sources